Q&A

ASK Fabrizio Benedetti about the placebo and nocebo effect

ASK Fabrizio Benedetti about the placebo and nocebo effect

ASK prominent neuroscientist and placebo expert Professor Fabrizio Benedetti how positive and negative beliefs and expectations affect health, symptoms and illness.

Q
What is the placebo effect, and why does it happen?
A

The placebo effect is the positive effect (clinical improvement) following the administration of an inert treatment (the placebo) with no specific therapeutic properties (water, flour, etc.). What matters is not so much the inert treatment but rather the psychosocial context around the patient, which induces positive expectations of benefit. In other words, a placebo is the whole ritual of the therapeutic act, which is made of many psychological and social factors. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHeF7rYz7uY

Q
What is the difference between placebo and nocebo?
A

Whereas a placebo effect is related to positive effects, the nocebo effects are attributable to negative expectations, which, in turn, lead to clinical worsening.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23899563/

Q
What are some clever uses of the placebo effect?
A

Some possible implications are represented by the administration of placebos interspersed among real treatments, according to a paradigm such as “drug-drug-drug-placebo-drug-drug-placebo-drug-etc.” In the long run, this may lead to a reduction of drug intake.

https://physoc.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1113/JP271322

Q
Does everyone respond to placebos?
A

There are people responding to placebos and people who do not. It is not clear why this happens, but personality traits, genetic factors, and social factors may play an important role. This is a future challenge for placebo research.

Q
Are all diseases equally placebo-responsive?
A

Whenever psychological factors are involved, such as in pain, motor performance, anxiety, depression, the placebo effect is important. Conversely, placebos cannot kill the bacteria of pneumonia, nor can they prevent pregnancy, nor can they stop cancer growth.

Q
Is healing from placebos all in your mind?
A

Not exactly. There are many physiological and biochemical effects both in the brain and in the whole body, such as the release of endorphins and endocannabinoids.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3055515/

Q
Does more frequent dosing increase the placebo effect?
A

Learning is important. If a drug is given several days in a row and then replaced with a placebo, the placebo effect is usually huge. By contrast, if a placebo is given for the first time, the placebo effect is smaller, or it does not occur at all.

https://www.nature.com/news/parkinson-s-patients-trained-to-respond-to-placebos-1.19341

Q
Could the placebo effect be just regression to the mean?
A

The very definition of placebo effect is that it is a true psychobiological effect. Regression to the mean may play a role, sometimes important, but it has nothing to do with the real psychological placebo effect.

Q
Does your research suggest that we shouldn't be rejecting complementary medicine such as homeopathy and ancient healing techniques due to their lack of scientific evidence?
A

No, our research is only aimed at better understanding the psychological component of any treatment, be it pharmacological or not. Complementary and alternative medicine is outside mainstream medicine because, as far as we know today, they lack rigorous scientific evidence.

Q
Is it attention and nurturance from a health practitioner, i.e., a healing relationship that may account for a large part of the placebo effect?
A

Yes, the social encounter between the therapist and the patient plays a crucial role. Any word, behaviour, the attitude of the therapist may potentially influence the therapeutic outcome and the course of a disease.

Q
Could some of the side-effects people are experiencing from the COVID vaccine be attributed to the nocebo effect? Are there cultural differences in vaccine side-effects dependent on what the dominant ideas about vaccines are?
A

Yes, the psychological and social effects of mass phenomena are very important, as they may influence how we approach and deal with vaccination. Indeed, cultural factors play a role virtually in all circumstances.

Q
Have you looked at how much a doctor's belief about a treatment's effectiveness influences the outcome for a patient? And for example, to look out for pessimistic doctors?
A

Pessimistic doctors are characterized by bad behaviours and attitudes, and these in turn can be transmitted and communicated to their patients, either consciously or unconsciously. If I am a patient and perceive uncertainty in my doctor, this may have a tremendous impact on my psychological status.

Q
Can excessive knowledge about what can go wrong in the body harm you - in a nocebo way?
A

Yes, if I know everything about what is happening in my body, my attention will be directed to my body more than others. And this may increase my perception of symptoms and pathological states.

Q
If placebo effects cause actual change, then why have we not developed treatments based on this phenomenon rather than relying on medication that can have harmful side effects?
A

There are treatments, either pharmacological or not, that are more effective than placebos (just consider antibiotics and powerful painkillers). Therefore, in these cases, it is better to use effective treatments, as they can improve the clinical outcome more than placebos.

You may also like